Grading scale and how it works

    I figured now would be the best time to clearly outline how my grading scale works and what criteria I use when assigning grades. I chose letter grades instead of a numerical scale because numbers can feel overly precise. If someone gives a spirit an 86 and another an 87, I always wonder what that single point difference truly represents. Letter grades allow for clearer distinctions in overall experience without pretending to measure something down to a decimal.

    When I first started my spirits journey, I didn’t want to give scores at all. My goal was simple: tell viewers whether something was worth buying or worth passing on. But in 2024, I changed my mindset and decided to bring more structure to my reviews.

    Below is the A–F grading scale I currently use. Grades are based on overall experience, balance, complexity, uniqueness, and value for the price. If adjustments are made over time, I’ll note any changes here for full transparency. 

A+ (Perfection) - This is the pinnacle of perfection, the nectar of the gods. When you think of an ideal pour, this bottle defines it. From the mash bill and aging process to the nose, palate, and finish, every aspect is flawlessly executed. Whether it’s a big-name brand or a hidden gem from a craft distillery, this bottle speaks for itself. It’s worth buying, savoring, and even backing up (if cost permits).

A (Excellent) - This bottle is exceptional in every sense. The mash bill, age, and craftsmanship all come together to create something special. The nose is complex, the palate is well-rounded, and the finish lingers in all the right ways. It’s not quite perfection, but it’s unquestionably worth seeking out. Whether you’re savoring it neat or showcasing it for friends, this bottle shines as an excellent example of what whiskey can be.

A- (Amazing) - A standout pour that sits just below elite territory. The notes are engaging, the balance is impressive, and the finish leaves you wanting more. It may lack the depth, uniqueness, or polish needed to reach the A tier, but it’s still a fantastic bottle worth owning and recommending without hesitation.

B+ (Great) - This is a strong, enjoyable whiskey that delivers above-average quality. The nose and palate may have a standout feature or two, but the overall experience might fall short of being transformative. It’s an excellent value for its price point, and while it won’t blow anyone’s mind, it will leave most people impressed. Worth grabbing, especially if you spot it on a good deal.

B (Above average) - A solid pour that gets the basics right. The nose is inviting, the palate is balanced, and the finish is satisfying, even if nothing particularly stands out. It may lack complexity or fall short in one or two areas, but it’s a reliable choice that holds up well. Great for casual sipping or mixing, it’s a bottle that’s worth trying, though not necessarily hunting down.

B- (Fairly good) - This bottle lands slightly above the average but misses a few key marks. Maybe the nose is promising but doesn’t fully deliver on the palate, or the finish feels a bit abrupt. It’s enjoyable but leaves room for improvement. A fair option for casual drinking, but you might pause before purchasing it again if the price isn’t right.


C+ (Slightly above average) - This bottle edges slightly above average but lacks distinct character. While it may offer a pleasant nose or a smooth palate, it doesn’t separate itself from the crowd. It’s serviceable and enjoyable in the right setting, but not memorable enough to seek out again.

C (Average) - A straightforward pour that does exactly what it needs to, but nothing more. The nose, palate, and finish are all serviceable, with no glaring flaws or standout qualities. It’s the kind of bottle you might keep on hand for mixing or a casual drink without much thought. There’s nothing wrong with it, but it won’t leave a lasting impression either. A no-frills, middle-of-the-road whiskey.

C- (Slightly below average) - This bottle falls just shy of hitting the mark. The nose or palate might feel off, the balance is likely lacking, or the finish ends too quickly. It’s not outright bad, but it needs a push to reach a truly average standard. You could sip it or use it as a mixer, but it’s unlikely to make its way back into your collection unless there are improvements or a big sale.


D+ (Below average) - This bottle falls short in several areas. The nose might be muted, the palate flat or unbalanced, and the finish uninspiring. Perhaps it has one or two redeeming qualities, but they’re overshadowed by noticeable flaws. While it’s drinkable, it lacks the character to make it worth buying unless deeply discounted or out of curiosity.

D (Poor) - A disappointing experience overall. The nose is likely weak or off, the palate is unbalanced, and the finish may be forgettable or unpleasant. There’s not much redeeming here, and it struggles to justify even a low price. While it might be drinkable in a pinch, this is a bottle best avoided unless there’s nothing else around.

D- (Barely passing) - This pour struggles to meet even the lowest expectations. The nose, palate, and finish are all lackluster, with little to recommend it. At best, it’s drinkable in a pinch; at worst, it’s a regretful purchase. Not worth hunting, buying, or even sipping unless you’re desperate or curious about its shortcomings.


F (Do not buy) - This bottle fundamentally misses the mark. The nose is uninspiring, the palate is unpleasant or unbalanced, and the finish might be non-existent, or worse, lingering for all the wrong reasons. The price, no matter how low, doesn’t justify the experience. While I hesitate to call anything a "drain pour," this bottle comes dangerously close. If you must try it, let it be only out of curiosity and only if it’s free. Otherwise, avoid at all costs.