Peerless Distilling Rum Finished Bourbon Whiskey Review.

-

 Peerless Distilling Rum Finished Bourbon Whiskey Review.


    Every now and then, a bottle sneaks into Indiana that makes you stop mid–liquor store lap. This was one of those moments. Peerless is already a distillery I have a soft spot for, their Double Oak Bourbon and Rye are mainstays for me, but the Rum Barrel Finished Bourbon? That’s a rare sighting here. This is batch 02 of the release and while the label keeps its secrets on age and finishing time, curiosity got the better of me. I cracked it open with my wife the other night, and the experience was… not exactly what I’d pictured from Peerless.

    Peerless keeps things true to their style here: barrel proof, sweet mash, and crafted with their signature approach to balance and body. This batch began life as their straight bourbon before moving into rum barrels for finishing. It’s a bold concept — in theory, a marriage of deep Kentucky bourbon richness with tropical rum complexity. Peerless doesn’t typically chase sky-high ABVs, preferring to let the barrel speak without overproof heat, which gives their whiskeys a softer edge while keeping flavor intact.


For the full video review visit the link here!: https://youtu.be/aNOAYNstV1A


Age Statement: N/A.


ABV: 54.55%. (Barrel proof).


Mashbill: N/A.


Area of Distillation: Kentucky, USA.


Finishing: Rum Barrel. (N/A on finishing time).


Appearance: Dark Mahogany.



On the nose: 

    The first inhale leans heavily bourbon rather than rum. Deep oak is front and center, backed by baking spices, brown sugar, and just a whisper of dark molasses. There’s a subtle plum or raisin note tucked away, and hints of chocolate powder mix with vanilla-caramel bourbon character. While pleasant, it doesn’t immediately read as rum-finished, the funk, tropical lift, or spiced-sugar punch you’d expect just aren’t prominent here.



Taste: 

    The rum influence peeks through more in the sip than the sniff. A mild tropical spice hum rides over a core of brown sugar, charred oak, and drizzled caramel. There’s a bit of molasses, some earthy char, and a faint leather edge. Dark fruit, fig or plum,lingers in the back ground, while a sweet undertone hints at the rum’s touch. Still, it’s restrained, leaning classic bourbon with only a gentle nudge toward its finishing cask.



Finish: 

    Medium in length with warm spice, charred oak, and a trailing molasses sweetness. The rum note fades quickly, leaving mostly bourbon character to close things out.



Final Thoughts: 

    As a bourbon, this is solid, balanced, flavorful, and easy to appreciate for its Kentucky roots. As a rum-finished bourbon, it underdelivers. The price stings given the limited influence of the finishing cask. If I judged it blind, I’d give it a B– to C+ as a straight bourbon. But in the rum-finish category, it lands closer to a C. Worth grabbing a pour to try, but not one I’d chase a bottle of unless you’re a Peerless completist. Here’s hoping batch three finds a little more of that rum magic.



Rating: C. (Slightly below average)


Cost: $119.99 for 750ml.


For the full video review visit the link here!: https://youtu.be/aNOAYNstV1A


Social platforms to follow: https://linktr.ee/thelastcallyt

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Old 55 Distillery Single Barrel Cask Strength Sweet Corn Bourbon Whiskey Review.

-
Image
Old 55 Distillery Single Barrel Cask Strength Sweet Corn Bourbon Whiskey Review.           Old 55 Distillery is a small craft operation tucked away in Newtown, Indiana, just south of Lafayette, and they’ve built a name for themselves by doing something very few dare to try, making bourbon with 100% sweet corn. I’ve crossed paths with a few of their spirits before and have always respected the level of care they bring to the table: all distilling, aging, and bottling is done in-house, with a heavy emphasis on local grains. Their Bottled-in-Bond Sweet Corn Bourbon is the bottle most people around here know, but this release, a single barrel, cask strength version, was something I’d only ever seen at the Market District in Carmel, Indiana.       Sweet corn isn’t just a novelty for Old 55, it’s an expensive, labor-intensive choice. A bushel of the common yellow dent corn runs about $4 (2020 prices), but the sweet corn they use costs over $1,...
Read more

Maker's Mark Cask Strength 7 Year Bourbon Whiskey Review.

-
Image
Maker's Mark Cask Strength 7 Year Bourbon Whiskey Review.           As 2025 winds down, Makers Mark surprised everyone with what appears to be a limited-age-stated run of their beloved cask strength bourbon. I’ve always had a soft spot for Makers Mark. It wasn’t a brand I fell in love with immediately, but somewhere along the way, it became a comfort bottle, a pour I reached for between bigger, flashier releases. Their lineup consistently offers strong value, and while I still haven’t tried the Cellar Aged, the rest are genuinely solid. Seeing this on the shelf at standard cask strength pricing made it an easy pickup.      This release is still their classic wheated bourbon, although Makers Mark doesn’t publish the exact mash bill. The side label offers some intriguing production details: a 110-proof barrel entry, 378 hand-rotated and hand-selected casks, and the note that each batch is “aged to taste.” That wording alone hints at future vari...
Read more

Dovetail Distillery Cut Throat Oat Whiskey Review.

-
Image
Dovetail Distillery Cut Throat Oat Whiskey Review.      I received this spirit as a review sample from Dovetail Distillery, linked here . It is important to clarify this did not impact the ratings of this review.           Dovetail Distillery, currently the smallest craft distillery based in Nevada. Currently the distillery is doing quite a bit with unique grains and one of those grains is Oats. Oats can be a fun grain your craft distilleries can play around with and add a unique profile to their spirits. Their Cutthroat Oat Whiskey is no exception, bringing three unique grains to the mix. After being double distilled it is aged for two years in custom char/toast American white oak 15-gallon barrels. This barrel size can be tricky, it does take a keen eye and palate to make sure this size of barrel doesn't take over.       Given my fascination with oat-based spirits, I was eager to dive into this bottle and see how Dovetai...
Read more