Bondstone Triple Oak Bourbon Whiskey Review.
Bondstone is one of those brands you’ll most often spot at Total Wine, living in the Spirit Direct section and sparking plenty of debate among bourbon fans. Some folks write those bottles off immediately, but the reality is a bit more nuanced. Spirit Direct can mean in-house bottlings, sourced projects, or partnerships with smaller distilleries, and Bondstone sits firmly in that sourced-project lane. This Triple Oak release had been on my radar for a while, and when Batch 2 landed in mid-2025 with a discount attached, curiosity finally won.
Presentation-wise, Bondstone absolutely nails it. The bottle looks fantastic on the shelf and in the glass, immediately setting expectations higher than you might assume for a sourced bourbon. While Batch 1 passed me by due to pricing, this felt like the right moment to see whether the liquid could live up to the looks.
Details are limited, as expected with a sourced product. Bondstone does not disclose the distillery or mash bill, though industry speculation points toward Wilderness Trail, a distillery known for contract distillation. What we do know is that this starts as a four-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon that undergoes a double oak process, followed by additional aging with toasted oak staves, hence the “Triple Oak” designation.
Initially, I questioned the use of staves rather than a full third barrel. After spending time with a wide range of double oak bourbons recently, the choice makes sense. Staves allow for more controlled oak influence without pushing the whiskey into over-oaked territory, and they offer a more cost-effective way to build complexity.
Age Statement: +4 years.
ABV: 45%.
Mash bill: N/A. (Rumored to be Wilderness Trail High rye mash bill).
Area of Distillation: Danville, Kentucky.
Finishing: New charred oak & toasted oak staves.
Appearance: Deep mocha.
On the nose:
On the nose:
The nose is immediately impressive. Light chocolate, caramel, and vanilla lead the way, followed by notes of fresh-baked chocolate brownies and custard. There’s a layered oak sweetness here that feels mature and well-integrated, with gentle spice and a touch of tannin. It smells far older than four years, with no youthful grain or sharp ethanol to be found.
Taste:
The palate is lighter than the nose suggests, but still enjoyable. Vanilla cream, custard, cinnamon stick, and a subtle rye-driven spice come through first. Oak is front and center without overwhelming the sip, and a cocoa powder note adds depth. The mouthfeel is respectable for 45% ABV, coating the palate cleanly and evenly.
Finish:
The finish is medium in length, leaning sweet and oak-forward. A slight bitterness creeps in toward the end, flirting with over-oaked territory but never crossing the line. As the whiskey opens up, green apple and a mild tartness emerge, adding a bit of brightness to the overall profile.
Final Thoughts:
Bondstone Triple Oak is one of those bottles that quietly defies expectations. It’s approachable, easy-drinking, and surprisingly well-balanced for a multi-oak bourbon at this proof. Pricing remains the biggest hurdle. At its $70 MSRP, it’s a tougher sell, but closer to the low-$60 range, it starts to make sense, especially when compared to other premium double and triple oak offerings.
While I still wish we had more transparency about the source and mash bill, the experience in the glass is undeniably enjoyable. This is a bourbon I’m genuinely interested in revisiting after some time and oxidation.
Rating: B (Above average).
Cost: $69.99 for 750ml.
Social platforms to follow me: https://linktr.ee/thelastcallyt
Comments
Post a Comment